82 Comments
User's avatar
Anton Zaides's avatar

Wow, I had no idea there was so much work behind it! You make the growth seem so effortless :)

And I'm very surprised about the LinkedIn stats, 150 per post is HUGE.

I also celebrate 1 year, while having a different journey :)

A very fast growth at the beginning, reaching 2k new subs a month between 5k and 10k, and then slowing to a CRAWL. Now it's around 200-300 a month, with most posts having a negative effect (more people unsubscribe than subscribe).

But I probably had it coming, except posting on LinkedIn I didn't do anything πŸ˜… I relied too heavily on recommendations.

Expand full comment
Tom Orbach's avatar

I spent 4 years building a LinkedIn community, it's nice to finally "pick the fruits" of it :)

Expand full comment
Aakash Gupta's avatar

Love this breakdown! Short pieces is so counter-intuitive.

But your most viral one indeed did have insane value not found on Google.

True Smart Brevity.

Thanks for sharing.

Expand full comment
Tom Orbach's avatar

100% agreed! Thanks Aakash for being there with me along this journey πŸ™Œ

Expand full comment
MichaΕ‚ Poczwardowski's avatar

Thank you for listing all these tactics, Tom!

This is pure gold in terms of showing all these diversifications that compound into the final result.

What is your take on Substack Notes?

Expand full comment
Tom Orbach's avatar

I'm not very active here on Notes, so can't say for sure :)

Expand full comment
MichaΕ‚ Poczwardowski's avatar

Thanks for the answer, Tom πŸ™‡β€β™‚οΈ β€” if you are not active, it means that it is not contributing much to the result.

Notes remain one of the only places where we do not get penalised for linking outside of the platform, as its users stay within the Substack Network πŸ™ˆ

Expand full comment
Lydia Sugarman's avatar

I always feel like Notes is a distraction from the main event even though I know it’s free promotion.

Expand full comment
🎲 Monetization Product Manager's avatar

Love πŸ₯° newsletter.

And I’m an accountant not a marketer!

Pure inspiration ❀️

Expand full comment
Tom Orbach's avatar

It's so humbling to have readers who are non-marketers! Thank you πŸ™

Expand full comment
Kyle Poyar's avatar

And now I’m feeling lazy… 🀣

Expand full comment
Tom Orbach's avatar

Haha πŸ˜‚ tho I'm pretty sure your growth rate is faster than mine πŸ€“

Expand full comment
Philippa Mayall's avatar

To be fair to regular people, you do have a unique skill set that’s enabled you to produce unique products that actually work. Dunno what the point of me telling you this was, but it’s always nice to hear how good you are πŸ˜‚πŸ˜Š

Expand full comment
Lydia Sugarman's avatar

But it’s backed up by a lot of plain ol’ hard work and dedication which makes all the difference.

Expand full comment
Philippa Mayall's avatar

No doubt. I don’t think there’s a creator who doesn’t put the sweat in. I’m under no illusions about the effort most things, that look easy, take to succeed. I yearn for it myself but I’m struggling with direction and it’s hard to write with oomph when I can’t quite imagine the audience and how it relates to them.

Good news is the hardwork is fueled by passion and it feels less like work this way.

Expand full comment
Tom Orbach's avatar

Just start Philippa, as soon as you enter the feedback loop you'll know what to do :)

Expand full comment
Philippa Mayall's avatar

That’s very true. I’m so slow though. Thats my biggest challenge. But I think when I get going I’ll be able to develop systems to overcome that. And I’m very distracted. It’ll get better though.

Expand full comment
Lydia Sugarman's avatar

Write for yourself. Your audience will find you.

Expand full comment
The Autistic Rebel ~ MrJoe's avatar

That? absolutely not true. Does Tom?

Expand full comment
Kevin George's avatar

One of the best Substack growth articles I’ve ever read… and I’ve read a few…

Expand full comment
Tom Orbach's avatar

Woah! Thanks Kevin :)

Expand full comment
Beniamin Raszek's avatar

Thanks for the value Tom!

Expand full comment
Josh Hinton's avatar

Thank you for sharing all of this valuable information, and thanks for the book recommendation. I am always looking for those.

Expand full comment
Tom Orbach's avatar

Huh, I might write a full "my all-time favorite marketing books" article. Would you be interested in that Josh?

Expand full comment
Matt Snyder's avatar

SO MUCH VALUE packed into this! Thanks for sharing!

Expand full comment
Tom Orbach's avatar

Thank you Matt! Glad you liked it :)

Expand full comment
Ruth Alva's avatar

You deserve the growth πŸ’―%!

I love how much value you offer, even in free posts like these. So inspiring to see your journey and you’ve motivated me to step up my game. Thanks! 😊

Expand full comment
Tom Orbach's avatar

Thank you, Ruth! I really appreciate it

Expand full comment
Ido Vadavker's avatar

This is your most powerful post yet!

I read Lenny's post about how he reached 500,000 every few weeks to remind myself what to focus on. (https://www.lennysnewsletter.com/p/500000)

I think I'll have to reread your post every few weeks as well!

You are doing awesome job man, keep going 🀩

Expand full comment
Tom Orbach's avatar

Most powerful yet? Wow, now I must beat that with my future articles lol. Thank you!

Expand full comment
Lora L.'s avatar

Nice way to find out I'm in the top 1%.

So when is the next event?

Expand full comment
Tom Orbach's avatar

You'll be the first to know ;)

Expand full comment
Malisa Santigul's avatar

Super helpful. Thanks for sharing your experience and strategy.

Expand full comment
Libby Shively McAvoy's avatar

Great tips and ideas. Thank you for sharing. I am just getting started on Substack.

Expand full comment
Seth Purcell's avatar

Awesome post, Tom! BTW if we were looking to hire someone able to execute the tactics in this list (and ideally generate all these tactics and others), what job title should they have/would they have at their current role? Is it just "Growth Marketer" or something more specific?

Expand full comment
Tom Orbach's avatar

Yup, I can't think of any specific roles other than growth marketer (perhaps "Organic Marketer?"). Growth Marketing is, unfortunately, very broad - but I'd try to look for people that answer these questions well: https://www.marketingideas.com/p/my-favorite-job-interview-questions

Expand full comment